The battle over DOS's proposed regulations continues. See the Washington Post article here:
Monday, October 3, 2016
Some of you may have heard that on September 8, 2016, Department of State issued proposed new regulations for adoption agencies. You can read them for yourselves here:
ABI and the rest of the adoption community have several very serious concerns with the proposed changes. You can read about them here: http://saveadoptions.org/letter/. ABI’s Lucy Armistead and Diana Boni were involved with drafting the concerns listed, and we fully support each and every one of them. All of us agree that every child should remain with his birth family, or in his birth country, if possible But we also believe that NO child should ever grow up in an institution. Every child has the right to a permanent, loving family.
Unfortunately, there are powerful government and NGO forces who continue to believe that children are better off in orphanages than international adoptive homes. These regulations are another attempt to put that policy into force.
We need your help to stop DOS from regulating the majority of adoption agencies out of existence. Please visit http://saveadoptions.org/ to sign the petition. It is quick and easy to do. Encourage your friends and relatives to do so as well. We must speak up to save the agencies who are often the only voices for institutionalized and abandoned children.
Monday, July 18, 2016
Meeting day, with a capital M. First to the Consulate. Once upon a time, when I first started working in Haiti, DOS was difficult. We had a few workers who weren’t very enthusiastic, and one who was perfectly vile. Fortunately he didn’t last long. Over the last few years, we’ve been blessed with true allies in finding ways to follow the law and bring kids home. I’m especially grateful to have just that sort in the Adoptions Unit now. We have a lot to discuss.
First, we go over what a ‘normal’ adoption process might look like. I need to know – we’ve only had ONE Hague process Haiti adoption completed for the US! The second one will also be a pretty standard case, but my case with the Puerto Rican family is unusual, in that the family legally adopted the child prior to the issuance of an Article 5 letter from DOS. I’ll explain all those Articles and steps in another post, but for now, suffice it to say that it’s pretty involved, and if you don’t do everything in the right order you’ll have an enormous mess to clean up.
In this case, my client family followed the specific and wildly inaccurate advice of a licensed attorney who apparently did not know much about immigration law or international adoptions. We had to obtain the first-ever letter of permission from IBESR to proceed with a Hague adoption that was completed out of order. Obtaining that letter took a truly monumental effort on behalf of some friends of the family, my partner and myself. Not to mention several US government employees.
Because we’re sort of backwards and upside down in this case, the Adoptions Unit officer explains the procedure we need to follow. He also explains why, because the future lawyer in me always questions everything for my clients and he’s a lawyer too. But it seems that he’s worked out the fastest possible way to get M home with all the i’s dotted and t’s crossed. And then, just because he’s a nice guy, he agrees to try change the family’s visa appointment so that they can attend it and not have to reschedule their flight home. Honest- the people at DOS are not heartless bureaucrats.
He proves this point even further when we go over all the possible options for getting my dear O out of Haiti depending upon her TB status. I tell him that I understand it’s just one child, but she means a lot to me. He tells me that she’s just one child, and she means a lot to him too. They all do. I think for some of the USG staff, working on messy cases is even more painful than it is for me and my colleagues. They are the ones who have to say no, and they do understand the consequences that befall the kids when they do.
Next I meet with USCIS, who has agreed to see me on ridiculously short notice even though I argue with them every time I meet them. This time is no exception, and all three ladies in the unit are present for the meeting. Good thing I don’t get intimidated easily!
We discuss three of my cases. I don’t get everything I want, but I come out basically satisfied with the meeting and which battle I’m going to win, which I’ll concede, and which I might have to revisit. USCIS is not looking for trouble either. It’s just that our agency often takes on really complex cases, which are more involved and challenging than the ‘average’ adoption. Our ordinary cases are going through nicely, with no debate needed.
Next I meet Dr. Bernard in his office downtown. We go over our mutual case load, talk politics, and discuss his desire to expand the school at New Life Link to the community. It’s a remarkable program he has started. The kids speak English. Like, really speak it. Not just memorized phrases. They are using the Abeca curriculum. Many of the kids are at or approaching grade level. They will have a huge advantage post-adoption. I offer to put him in touch with a professional grant writer that I know to see if she’d like to donate some time and expertise to a worthy and proven cause.
Finally, I am supposed to visit one last potential orphanage partner. But the torrential rains have made access impossible. I just can’t get there. Frustrating! Instead Franck and I head to the airport. I hope he’s not tired of me after our very long day together, because we end up sitting in the car for two hours waiting for a late flight. And then it turns out the people we were waiting for were not on the flight at all. Even Franck comments that we wasted a lot of time – a complaint I’ve never heard him make before in all these years. As we pull out of the parking lot, it begins to rain and then to pour. Our drive home through streets that resemble flooding rivers jammed with stalled traffic takes around an hour and a half. It’s fully dark and most of supper is gone by the time we finally reach the guest house, and I feel like a wrung-out sponge. The remains of a marvelous dinner taunt me. I eat some of what little is left, but Susan saves the day by magically producing ice cream.
It’s my last night in Haiti. I am surrounded by family and friends. I have chocolate ice cream, good conversation, and the knowledge of some tasks accomplished. My cold shower awaits. It’s all good.
Sunday, July 17, 2016
Sunday is supposed to be a day off. But with only seven days on the ground, I don’t have time for a whole day off. My first meeting is scheduled for 8:00 am, and it is truly serendipitous. The family is Pureto Rican. Susan referred them to me for cleanup of a really tangled, complex independent adoption. They are the first US family to receive a letter from IBESR authorizing an out of order adoption. It feels like coming full circle to meet here in Haiti with Susan, and I really enjoy meeting their delightful little girl. She’s happy about meeting us too, once I convince her that I am not a doctor and that I am not going to give her any shots at all.
My next meeting is with Sonia Andre. For some reason we mostly speak in English this time, which feels a bit odd. We usually stick with Kreyol. Well, this way is a lot easier for me! We go over our case load too. It sounds like we’ll have good news for several families quite soon, as Sonia is seeing a lot of progress too.
Finally, it is time to rest. As a group, most of us go to the Karibe hotel which offers a great poolside lunch and pool pass package. Once again, it rains, but when you are sitting in a hot tub with a bubble jet massaging your calves, getting even wetter just doesn’t matter. I cheerfully procrastinate an enormous spreadsheet for Margarette to take to IBESR first thing Monday morning until late into the night, and I can’t even feel sorry for doing so.
Saturday, July 16, 2016
It’s Saturday, but it’s still a workday for me. Delia gets up quietly in the dark to make her flight, but I have so much to do I get up soon afterwards to get started.
I begin with two client meetings. ABI works with families who live in Haiti and want to adopt a relative or a child placed with them by IBESR. It’s hard work, but necessary and interesting. Susan sits in with me on the first meeting, with the family’s permission, while I go over their various options for adoption of the child they have raised since infancy. Susan has a strong interest in immigration law and the interesting complexities of relative adoptions. I have an interest in these families who sacrifice so much to live in Haiti and serve in whatever way they can. They tend to be flexible, strong, and fascinating. I truly admire the full time Haiti warriors. This is not an easy country to live in as an ex-pat.
Next, Margarette and I finally get to go through our large mutual case load. She’s got quite a bit of progress to report. Things will always be extremely difficult in Haiti, but at least now it seems like we’re getting somewhere. The past two years, it’s often felt like we are banging our heads against a wall of bureaucracy in an effort to knock it down. Now, our foreheads (and feet) are still sore, but at least the wall is a bit more flexible.
|They're Back!! BRESMA Alumni.|
After my meetings, it’s time to do something a long time coming. This is a photo of six grown BRESMA alumni, ages 18-24. Each and every one of them is either in college or working or both. Every one of them is here to visit their biological families. Every one of them is a happy, independent young adult. They are strong, confident, outspoken with their opinions. Their lives renew my faith in my work. Each of them lost a great deal when they left behind their culture, language, ethnicity, and country. But it would appear that each has gained as well as lost. There are many things a family can give that even the best orphanage can never match.
The current BRESMA kids are fascinated to meet my own adopted children. It’s a glimpse at their own future, and it spurs a fast and urgent round of, “do I have a Maman Blan?” “When are my parents coming to visit?” “When can I go on the plane?” Adoptive families try to convey to me the urgency of their cases, but truly I know how important it is that kids go home as quickly as possible. I am answerable to each and every one of these children to perform to my utmost and bring them all home. Maybe someday they’ll come back to visit and stand in front of BRESMA too, grown and strong examples for those who still wait for families.
Friday, July 15, 2016
Haiti has an astonishing diversity of micro climates. My kids are in a desert in the north, where the earth is bone dry and everything seems to have spines and needles. Yesterday we visited the mountains above Petionville, which are a lush, verdant, tropical rain forest. Today we visit Mirebalais, which is green and forested with small trees. We drive through some of the desert area to get here, and then the environment abruptly changes to farmland and flowers. It is truly beautiful, and the views from the twisting road through the mountains are heart stopping. Heart stoppingly beautiful for Delia, Susan, and myself, heart stoppingly terrifying for Margarette who does NOT like mountain driving. It’s really quite brave of her to come. Although she’ll kill a cockroach that would have had me standing on a chair screaming like a little girl with one swift blow of her shoe, she is truly frightened of driving anywhere near a cliff. And there are miles of cliffs on this journey, most with minimal guardrails. I’m glad we got Denis Frantz to drive us today. He’s careful and sensible, and he knows Margarette’s feeling about fast driving on curves.
We almost pass Haiti Children’s Home’s new facility off the
new road, it has grown so much since last we visited. But the big wall and beautiful buildings
catch my eye and we turn around to enter.
HCH might be the most beautiful orphanage in Haiti. It’s set up as a community of group homes, each
of which is a whole lot nicer than my house in the States, around a common
playground. They have a school,
off-the-grid solar power, and water you can drink right out of the tap. I even try it myself, although I feel much
the same as I do when I see a big, big cockroach as I take a sip…
Delia has a few cases to go over with their director of
adoptions. Margarette is offering some
assistance with completing cases. It’s
hard enough when you don’t live two and a half hours from IBESR and the courts.
|Cottage at HCH|
Around thirty children live here in groups of eight with permanent house parents. It’s like a real family, with different ages, assigned chores, sibling squabbles, and lots of love and consistency. HCH does adoptions, but their system is so like a natural family environment, I’d be unsurprised to learn that none of them are suffering any developmental damage from living here. Some of the kids have special needs, and I relate that ABI has pretty good luck with finding families for such kids. I would be happy to work with HCH.
|Delia and a New Friend|
We manage to miss lunch – my third day in a row! – so we decide to stop by the Apparent Project on our way home. I’ve always wanted to go. The Apparent Project promotes family preservation through economic independence, and the products that their artisans make are beautiful. Anyone fundraising for anything should consider their program. Who wouldn’t want their amazing handmade jewelry? We have pizza at their second floor restaurant, then descend where I souvenir shop like a tourist.
We arrive home to find that the kids are all back, and what’s more two more young adult BREMSA alumni have joined us. The house is full to bursting, and I couldn’t be more proud of BRESMA’s ‘graduates.’
Thursday, July 14, 2016
Today we scatter to the winds, all over Haiti. My three kids and K head North to Cabaret. GE and her cousin go off with GE’s sisters, who are delightful, classy people. The apple didn’t fall far from the tree there – GE is just like them. I always liked that kid…
And we head off to the mountains, three raucous attorney types loose in Haiti! It will be a miracle if they don’t kick us off the island. I feel truly blessed to be accompanied not only by Delia Ramsbotham, managing director of Sunrise Family Services, but also by my friend Susan Levin, newly beginning her independent law practice. I’ve traveled with Delia before and she’s a delightful companion. This is Susan’s first trip to Haiti. All of us have a lot of experience in child welfare and a great interest in how the law relates to adoption and immigration.
Our first stop is a brief visit at GLA. Susan is amused by how we navigate in Haiti, which involves repeatedly calling for directions and asking people in the street about our location and destination. I’ve been to GLA dozens of times. I have a good sense of direction. But that doesn’t mean I’ll ever find the place on the first try. Haitian back roads are like a dropped handful of cooked spaghetti, and just about as easy to drive on. Eventually I recognize where we are and we arrive. Susan gets her first-ever look at a Haitian orphanage. I have to explain to her that this is not typical – GLA remains one of the finest child care facilities in Haiti. In fact, we are introduced to a tiny preemie who was brought here from the hospital for neo-natal intensive care. GLA is Haiti’s NICU. Baby and mother will stay here until she’s big enough to go home. Now, she is under two pounds and as fragile as a breath of air. I would be terrified to touch her. Instead we all sanitize our hands and play with other, sturdier babies. By the time we reach GLA’s roof top play area, it begins to pour. It’s earlier than usual for rain, but I seem to bring rain with me when I travel. At least it will cool the air down in Port au Prince.
|Outside Rivers of Hope|
Rivers of Hope is a beautiful facility, with ample room outside for the children and a very spacious home for just 30 children. Another one of the very best there is. Rachel’s English is superb. We discuss the various problems of Haiti, but Rachel doesn’t have the answers either. She agrees that things are definitely getting better as far as adoptions are concerned. We are seeing movement at last. She asks how my partner, Margarette Saint Fleur, is getting her Authorizations, as Rachel has really been struggling with IBESR to get her kids out. I’ll try to put the two of them in touch to see if Margarette has any special tricks. But I don’t think she does – I think she just goes there and sits all day, every day that they allow visitors, until they get sick of her and give her the documents that she needs to make her go away. That’s how we do things in Haiti.
In the late afternoon we head back down the mountain, hope renewed after visiting a few children for whom things have gotten better and will continue to get better still.
|Inside the House|